<img src="//bat.bing.com/action/0?ti=5065582&amp;Ver=2" height="0" width="0" style="display:none; visibility: hidden;">
Update from Care2
A community for good
helping you find great people
Contact | +1 (888) 655-8345
Request a Quote
  • Home
  • Recruit New Supporters
    • Overview
    • Audience Profile
    • Methodology
    • Pricing & ROI
    • Partner Network
  • Resources
    • Guides
    • Case Studies
    • Webinars
  • Advertise With Care2
    • Overview
  • Care2 Engagement Blog
Care2's Digital Engagement Blog
Learn how to grow your nonprofit through Donor Recruitment, Online Fundraising, Advocacy, and Social Media with Care2’s team of expert nonprofit professionals.

Direct Mail Isn’t Dying – But Sometimes I Wish It Would

by Mark Rovner on Aug 7, 2009

[Mark Rovner of Sea Change Strategies added his opinions to the spirited debate on the state of direct mail. Check out his thoughtful guest post below. - Allyson Kapin, Frogloop Blogger-In-Chief]

As long as I have been doing fundraising the “is direct mail dead” question has arisen with great regularity. Interestingly, the question is always raised by direct mail fundraising consultants -- and the answer is always unsurprisingly “no.”

Clouding the situation from the other side are the over-optimistic claims from the Internet world that it’ll all be online in a matter of a few years.

Full disclosure –professionally I fall on the “cyber”side of things, but I have a healthy respect for the financial importance of direct mail –for now and for the foreseeable future.

In his most recent defense of direct mail as we know it, Chuck Pruitt uses a self-serving study (sorry Chuck but it is) to claim that direct mail is a “life-cycle”thing and not a “generational thing.” He claims that eventually, we’ll age into the life stage in which we will become direct mail donors.

That’s kind of silly.

Let’s look at some reasons why:

  • Rapid and extensive adoption of online banking and bill-paying. I have no clue where my checkbook is on any given day. I am not alone. Responding to direct mail is intimately tied to bill-paying, and as the bill-paying ritual shifts online, so will a great deal of giving.
  • Online giving is for many organizations the dominant channel for acquiring new donors.
  • Online giving is already the dominant giving channel in emergency giving.

More fundamentally, the direct mail denialists overlook a genuine and powerful shift that is very much generational – a rejection of inauthentic communications.

Baby boomers are hard to fool. Gen-Ys are impossible to fool. That won’t change with age.

Why does it matter? Because in my experience there is no more inauthentic communications channel than direct mail.

  • Contrary to their public claims, direct mail fundraisers spend much more time thinking about the color or size of the envelope than they do the content. I’ve been in those meetings.
  • A huge proportion of direct mail includes mailing labels or other crap to make you feel guilty and give out of obligation – not a great way to establish a relationship. The worst manifestation of this is the mailers who tape a fifty cent piece or a quarter to a reply card.
  • Everything is an emergency – because that lifts response rates.
  • Many mailers resort to stunts like deliberately printing the address on the envelope upside down – because that lifts response rates.
  • One non-profit mailer put a variation of the US seal on the envelope and stamped it “Official Taxpayer Information.”
  • The patois of direct mail is loaded with hyperbole and stilted language – because it lifts response rates.

I’m not saying these tactics don’t work. If they didn’t work they wouldn’t be so commonplace. I am saying it’s all a little bit sleazy and dishonest, and we have three generations – boomers, Gen-X an Gen-Y who are progressively less tolerant of sleaze and manipulation than their forebears.

Is online fundraising perfect? Hell no. Do we find ourselves sometimes resorting to the same tactics? Regrettably yes. The current fascination with premiums among online fundraisers for instance is in my opinion a short-sighted mistake. Crap backpacks and other tchotchkes do not make for durable donor relationships regardless of the channel by which they are peddled.

Pruitt rightfully points out that online donors often have shorter lifespans as donors than mail-acquired donors. I would argue that is because the practice is immature and we are still learning the art of online stewardship. But that’s changing.

There’s nothing inherently “bad” about direct mail, but after three decades of hucksterish communication, the perception won’t wear off overnight. The sheer expense of mailing means that direct mail will almost certainly decline in its share of the overall communications mix.

If our direct mail brethren are smart, they’ll get beyond their denial about the world changing, and reinvent the medium to match the expectations and tastes of new generations of donors. If they don’t, then maybe it is time to be drafting the epitaph.

This article was written by Mark Rovner, the founder of the online communications firm Sea Change Strategies.

You should follow Frogloop on Twitter here

 

 

Topics: Online Fundraising, Direct Mail

Mark Rovner

Subscribe to Email Updates

Subscribe to RSS feeds
New Call-to-action
New Call-to-action

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

  • Online Fundraising (337)
  • Social Networking (333)
  • Trends (303)
  • Web 2.0 (230)
  • Online Marketing (165)
  • Online Advocacy (159)
  • Technology (127)
  • Nonprofit Events (94)
  • Marketing Research (89)
  • Email Marketing (83)
  • Online Organizing (75)
  • nptech (64)
  • Nonprofit (62)
  • Misc. (60)
  • Mobile (48)
  • Care2 Webinars (46)
  • Care2 News (39)
  • Video (37)
  • Nonprofit Benchmark Studies (33)
  • Integrated Marketing (27)
  • Metrics (25)
  • Lead Generation (24)
  • Guest Blogs (23)
  • fundraising (23)
  • Digital Strategy (21)
  • Case Studies (20)
  • Conferences (20)
  • Volunteering (18)
  • Direct Marketing (17)
  • Social Media (17)
  • Cause Marketing (13)
  • Online Advertising (13)
  • Care2 Case Studies (12)
  • Direct Mail (12)
  • Marketing (11)
  • Crowdsourcing (10)
  • Awards (8)
  • email fundraising (8)
  • SEO (7)
  • Blogging (5)
  • E-newsletters (5)
  • COVID19 (4)
  • Social Justice (3)
  • organizing (3)
  • remote work (3)
  • research (3)
  • web development (3)
  • CRM (2)
  • Google ads (2)
  • activism (2)
  • advocacy (2)
  • crowdfunding (2)
  • data (2)
  • donor data (2)
  • facebook (2)
  • payment processing (2)
  • peer-to-peer fundraising (2)
  • Democracy (1)
  • Election2020 (1)
  • Giving Tuesday (1)
  • Online Learning (1)
  • Politics (1)
  • Qgiv (1)
  • ROI (1)
  • SMS (1)
  • Twitter (1)
  • Voting (1)
  • Wordpress (1)
  • acquisition (1)
  • analytics (1)
  • board management (1)
  • business (1)
  • cyber bullying (1)
  • data security (1)
  • eBooks (1)
  • engagement (1)
  • harassment (1)
  • microsoft (1)
  • mobile fundraising (1)
  • mobile giving (1)
  • monthly giving (1)
  • online donations (1)
  • online harassment (1)
  • petitions (1)
  • report (1)
  • software (1)
  • survey (1)
Expand all

Authors List

  • Allyson Kapin (578)
  • Justin Perkins (54)
  • Hatef Yamini (41)
  • James OMalley (40)
  • Clinton OBrien (26)
  • Avi Kaplan (25)
  • care2team (24)
  • Jocelyn Harmon (17)
  • Ned Baker (16)
  • Jordan Wait (14)
  • Eric Rardin (13)
  • Justyn Hintze (9)
  • Lesley M. (9)
  • Geoff Livingston (8)
  • Karen Taggart (8)
  • Randy Paynter (8)
  • Care2 Team (7)
  • Carrie Saracini (7)
  • Amy Sample Ward (6)
  • Claire Kerr (6)
  • Matt Howes (6)
  • Alan Rosenblatt (5)
  • Neal Gorenflo (5)
  • Rob Wu (5)
  • Salima Mangalji (5)
  • Adrienne Royer (4)
  • Caitlin Ochs (4)
  • Heidi Bucheister (4)
  • Kara Fujita (4)
  • Ryann Miller (4)
  • Shayna Englin (4)
  • Allyson Kapin and Jared Seltzer (3)
  • Craig Newmark (3)
  • Dana Weissman (3)
  • Heather Holdridge (3)
  • Mark Rovner (3)
  • Michael L. (3)
  • Nancy Schwartz (3)
  • Susan Higgins (3)
  • Abby Jarvis (2)
  • Agata K. (2)
  • Alia Mckee (2)
  • Amil Husain (2)
  • Ann Yoders (2)
  • Colin Delany (2)
  • Deanna Zandt (2)
  • Frank Barry (2)
  • Garth Moore Michael Silberman and Liz Butler (2)
  • Gerard Tonti (2)
  • Ghazal Vaghedi (2)
  • Hilary Treat (2)
  • Holly Ross (2)
  • Ifdy Perez (2)
  • JD Lasica (2)
  • Jared Seltzer (2)
  • Jill Foster (2)
  • Justin Perkins and Mirm Kriegel (2)
  • Karen Zapp (2)
  • Kelly ONeal (2)
  • Kevin Carroll (2)
  • Kevin Gilnack (2)
  • Larissa Lawrence (2)
  • Maddie Grant (2)
  • Rachel Hartwick (2)
  • Robin Reed (2)
  • Shabbir J. Imber Safdar (2)
  • Steve Daigneault (2)
  • Steve MacLaughlin (2)
  • Ted Fickes (2)
  • Addison Waters (1)
  • Ailea Sneller (1)
  • Alejandra Guerrero (1)
  • Alexandra Bornkessel (1)
  • Ali Cherry (1)
  • Allen Kramer (1)
  • Allison Fine (1)
  • Allison Van Diest (1)
  • Allyson Goldsmith (1)
  • Amy Eisenstein (1)
  • Andrew Berry (1)
  • Anna Richter (1)
  • Annaliese Hoehling (1)
  • Ashley Hansen (1)
  • Beth Kanter (1)
  • Bethany Hertel (1)
  • Brock Warner (1)
  • Candace Clement (1)
  • Candace Cody (1)
  • Carl Diesing (1)
  • Casey Golden (1)
  • Cassandra Smallman (1)
  • Charles Lenchner and Elana Levin (1)
  • Chris Burley (1)
  • Craig Grella (1)
  • Daniel Bennett (1)
  • Danielle Marshall (1)
  • Darian Rodriguez Heyman (1)
  • David M. Lawson abd Lori Hood Lawson (1)
  • Debra Askanase (1)
  • De’Yonté Wilkinson (1)
  • Duane Raymond (1)
  • Elissa Leif and Barbara Haupt (1)
  • Elliot Greenberger (1)
  • Farra Trompeter (1)
  • Garth Moore (1)
  • Grant Cobb (1)
  • Grant Hensel (1)
  • Gretchen Barry (1)
  • Hilary S. (1)
  • Holly DeRuyter (1)
  • Ira Horowitz (1)
  • Jacob Smith (1)
  • Jacqueline Christy (1)
  • Jared Schwartz (1)
  • Jason Mogus (1)
  • Jeb Banner (1)
  • Jen Nedeau (1)
  • Jenna Sauber (1)
  • Jennifer Jones Ingram (1)
  • Jessica Edmonson (1)
  • Jessica Teal (1)
  • John Haydon (1)
  • John Killoran (1)
  • Joleen Ong (1)
  • Josh Hirsch (1)
  • Karen Kitchens (1)
  • Karen Uffelman (1)
  • Kari Saratovsky (1)
  • Karrie Wozniak (1)
  • Katya Andresen (1)
  • Kayla Coleman (1)
  • Kevin Penny (1)
  • Kira Marchenese (1)
  • Kivi Leroux Miller (1)
  • Lars Hasselblad Torres and Kate Mytty (1)
  • Laura Quinn (1)
  • Lori Finch (1)
  • Luis Hestres Kimberly Fountain and Alex Bea (1)
  • Madeleine Milan (1)
  • Mal Warwick (1)
  • Mari Tikkanen (1)
  • Marisa Taylor (1)
  • Marnie Webb (1)
  • Matt Hugg (1)
  • Melanie Mathos (1)
  • Michael Hoffman (1)
  • Michael Khoo (1)
  • Michael Silberman (1)
  • Michelle Coyle (1)
  • Michelle Murrain (1)
  • Moira Edwards (1)
  • Murad Bushnaq (1)
  • Nick Black (1)
  • Rachel Phan (1)
  • Rella Kaplowitz (1)
  • Riche Zamor and Matt Kelley (1)
  • Robbie Bernstein (1)
  • Robert J. Rosenthal (1)
  • Russ Ostler (1)
  • Sara Choe (1)
  • Sarah Massey (1)
  • Seth Oldmixon (1)
  • Shabbir Imber Safdar Kate Harle Dale Anania (1)
  • Shana Glickfield (1)
  • Shaun Dakin (1)
  • Shayna Englin and Shabbir Safdar (1)
  • Shirley Sexton (1)
  • Stacy Laiderman (1)
  • Stephen OKeefe (1)
  • Steve Andersen (1)
  • Steve Peretz (1)
  • Steve Shattuck (1)
  • Suki Lee (1)
  • Theresa Anoje (1)
  • Tim Forbes (1)
  • Tim Robinson (1)
  • Tracy Viselli (1)
  • Veronica Wilson (1)
  • Wayne Elsey (1)
Expand all

Logo-white

Care2.com is an online social action network with over 50 million members around the world. Hundreds of nonprofits and socially conscious brands work with us to connect with our highly engaged members and recruit new donors, members, supporters, and customers.

+ Learn more about Care2

Overview

  • Recruit New Supporters
  • Audience Profile
  • Methodology
  • Pricing & ROI

Contact us

Redwood City, CA
94065
United States
+1 (888) 655-8345
nonprofitservices@care2team.com

Learn with Care2

Care2's Digital Engagement Blog

Community Building Resources

Follow us:

Twitter

Linkedin

Facebook

 

Copyright © 2015 Care2.com | All Care2 terms of service and privacy policies apply
Featured logos are trademarks of their respective owners. Third party trademarks, logos and trade names appearing on the site are the property of their respective owners.