When you think of a capital campaign, it’s easy to imagine large, resource-rich organizations raising millions of dollars with ease. But here’s the truth: small nonprofits—those with annual budgets under $1 million—are not only capable of running successful capital campaigns but can excel in unique and meaningful ways.
The principles of capital campaigns remain the same regardless of size: they’re ambitious, focused efforts to fund transformative projects like new facilities, additional programs, or scholarship funds. And small shops are proving they have what it takes to reach these bold goals.
Let’s explore how small nonprofits make these campaigns work, dive into encouraging findings from recent research, and outline the seven key phases of a successful campaign.
Small Shops, Big Wins: The Stats
Recent data from Capital Campaign Pro’s State of Capital Campaigns benchmark study shows that small shops are thriving in their campaigns. Here are a few highlights:
- High Success Rates: Small organizations achieved campaign satisfaction rates comparable to larger ones; upwards of 95% of small organizations were happy with the results of their campaigns. Despite smaller goals, the average raised in small shop campaigns was $3.5 million!
- First-Time Campaign Wins: Most small shops were embarking on their first-ever campaign. The leap into capital campaigns often leads to significant organizational growth. However, you may consider working with a consultant in order to avoid common mistakes and missteps.
- Major Donor Relationships: Small shops reported stronger major donor relationships post-campaign than their larger counterparts. This is a testament to the personal touch they bring to fundraising.
One of the study’s standout findings? Small organizations were more likely to report enhanced fundraising systems and stronger internal capacity after their campaigns, setting the stage for future success.
7 Phases of a Successful Capital Campaign
The size of your organization really has no bearing on how you should approach a campaign. There is a time-tested model! Breaking a capital campaign into seven phases makes the process more manageable, no matter the size of your organization.
1. Pre-Campaign Planning (3–12 months)
The foundation of your campaign starts here. Assess your readiness by evaluating your board, staff, and fundraising systems. Use this phase to create your campaign’s working goal, case for support, and gift range chart.
2. Feasibility Study (2–4 months)
A thorough feasibility study tests your goals and case for support with key donors. For small shops, this phase is crucial in building donor relationships and confidence. Opt for a collaborative feasibility study model where organizational leaders interact directly with top donors.
3. Campaign Planning (2 months)
Finalize your strategy based on feedback gathered during the feasibility study. Build a comprehensive plan, including your timeline, policies, and volunteer committees.
4. Quiet Phase (6–24 months)
Focus on securing 70% or more of your goal from major gifts. This phase relies on personalized solicitation, strong storytelling, and direct engagement with your top prospects.
5. Campaign Kick-Off (1 day to 1 month)
A public announcement sets the tone for the rest of the campaign. Highlight your progress and invite the community to join the effort.
6. Public Phase (3+ months)
Broaden your appeal to all supporters. Small nonprofits often shine here by mobilizing their tight-knit communities.
7. Stewardship (Ongoing)
Celebrate your success and thank your donors. This phase builds lasting relationships that will support your next big project.
Challenges and How to Overcome Them
Small organizations face unique challenges in capital campaigns, such as limited budgets and fewer staff. However, these can be mitigated with smart planning. Here are a few tips:
- Invest wisely. Budget constraints are common, but campaigns remain highly cost-effective, with expenses typically under 10% of the goal. Allocate funds for critical areas like consultant support, additional staff, and new technology (like wealth screening tools).
- Secure leadership buy-in. Strong involvement from your executive director and board is a must. Their active participation can drive donor confidence and campaign success.
- Ride the waves of social and economic uncertainty. Don’t let uncertainty deter you. Many organizations have successfully conducted campaigns during crises (such as the COVID-19 pandemic) by communicating closely with donors and sharing their mission’s urgency.
Why Small Shops Succeed
Small nonprofits have an edge in personal relationships and community connections. Donors often feel deeply involved in campaigns, especially when approached authentically and with a clear vision.
Running a campaign also catalyzes internal growth. From upgrading to new levels of financial stability to honing major gift strategies, campaigns can elevate a small organization to new levels of impact and capacity.
If your small nonprofit has a big dream, a capital campaign could be the path to realizing it. With the right preparation and a strategic approach, your organization can join the ranks of small shops achieving remarkable results.
Remember, the only thing separating a $3 million campaign from a $30 million one is a few zeros at the end. Are you ready to add those zeros? Start planning your campaign today!
COMMENTS